False Rape & POCSO Case | Consensual Sex Can’t Become An Offence U/S 376 IPC Merely Over Refusal To Marry: Gauhati HC Acquits Man After 13 Years
ASSAM: The Gauhati High Court has acquitted a man sentenced to 20 years in jail in a rape and POCSO case, observing that a consensual physical relationship between two adults cannot be treated as rape merely because the man subsequently refuses to marry the woman.
The Division Bench of Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma passed the judgment on November 5, 2026, setting aside the man's conviction and sentence.
On September 12, 2013, the woman's mother filed a complaint alleging that the accused had repeatedly raped her allegedly 16-year-old daughter, who later became pregnant. The complaint was filed after the man refused to marry her.
On March 26, 2025, the Trial Court sentenced the man to 10 years of rigorous imprisonment under Section 376 IPC and 20 years under Section 6 of the POCSO Act, along with a total fine of Rs. 30,000.
The man's counsel challenged the conviction, highlighting serious contradictions in the woman's statements regarding her age and the place of the alleged rape. He also argued that the relationship was consensual.
During her cross-examination, the woman stated:
“All the incidents of sexual intercourse by the accused with me had taken place in my residence.”
The woman also stated that she had physical relations with the accused around 40–50 times. Regarding her age, she stated at the time of the first incident, I was 19 years old
However, she subsequently claimed that she was 17 years old at the time of the incident.
The High Court noted that the woman's birth certificate had never been exhibited before the Trial Court. Her ossification test report stated:
“No sign of recent intercourse.”
“Age is between 17 to 18 years.”
Referring to several Supreme Court judgments on age determination, the High Court considered the possible margin of error in medical examinations and extended the benefit of doubt to the accused regarding the woman's age.
In her earlier statement recorded under Section 164 CrPC, the woman had alleged that the incidents took place at the accused's house. She had also stated:
“As the settlement efforts failed, I filed this case. At present, I am seven months pregnant.”
The High Court found serious contradictions in her statements and concluded that her allegation of forcible sexual intercourse did not appear to be truthful.
Read Also:- Can A Married Woman File A False Promise Of Marriage Case Under Section 69 BNS?
Taking note of the circumstances surrounding the criminal complaint, the High Court observed:
“It is only because the appellant had subsequently declined to marry the victim that the victim's feelings for the appellant has turned sour, resulting in the registration of this case, to cause injury to the appellant.”
The Bench further observed:
“We are of the view that the present case is basically a case of the victim becoming bitter due to the appellant not marrying the victim.”
The High Court held that a change in the relationship between two consenting adults cannot turn consensual sexual intercourse into rape, observing:
“A sexual relation between two consenting adults cannot be said to be an offence.”
The Court also found that the Trial Court had wrongly sentenced the man under both IPC and POCSO provisions, contrary to Section 42 of the POCSO Act.
Accordingly, the Gauhati High Court set aside the conviction, acquitted the man of both rape and POCSO charges and ordered his immediate release, unless required in another case, bringing an end to a legal battle lasting over 13 years.
Read Also:- Supreme Court Quashes POCSO Conviction: Says ‘It Was Love, Not Crime’
EXPLANATORY TABLE OF LAWS AND SECTIONS
| Law / Section | What It Means | Application In This Case |
|---|---|---|
| Section 342 IPC | Punishment for wrongful confinement. | Included in the charge sheet. |
| Section 375 IPC | Defines rape. | Relevant to examining the rape allegations. |
| Section 376 IPC | Punishment for rape. | Man was sentenced to 10 years and later acquitted. |
| Section 417 IPC | Punishment for cheating. | Included in the charge sheet. |
| Section 3(a) POCSO Act | Defines a form of penetrative sexual assault against a child. | Formed the basis of the POCSO allegations. |
| Section 5(j)(ii) POCSO Act | Aggravated penetrative sexual assault resulting in pregnancy. | Invoked following the woman's pregnancy. |
| Section 5(l) POCSO Act | Aggravated penetrative sexual assault committed repeatedly. | Invoked over allegations of repeated sexual assault. |
| Section 6 POCSO Act | Punishment for aggravated penetrative sexual assault. | Man was sentenced to 20 years and later acquitted. |
| Section 42 POCSO Act | Provides for alternate punishment for specified overlapping offences. | High Court held that sentencing under both provisions was improper. |
| Section 164 CrPC | Recording of statements and confessions before a Magistrate. | Woman's earlier statement contradicted her court testimony. |
| Section 313 CrPC | Examination of the accused by the court. | Accused was examined during the trial. |
| Section 94 Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 | Procedure for determining age. | Applied to determine the woman's age. |
| Rule 12(3) Juvenile Justice Rules, 2007 | Prescribes the earlier procedure for age determination. | Discussed through Supreme Court precedents. |
| Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969 | Governs registration of births and deaths. | Woman's birth certificate was never exhibited. |
| Section 166A IPC | Public servant disobeying specified legal directions. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 354A IPC | Sexual harassment. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 354B IPC | Assault with intent to disrobe a woman. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 354C IPC | Voyeurism. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 354D IPC | Stalking. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 370 IPC | Human trafficking. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 370A IPC | Exploitation of trafficked persons. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 376A IPC | Rape resulting in death or persistent vegetative state. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 376AB IPC | Rape of a girl below 12 years. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 376B IPC | Non-consensual sexual intercourse by a husband during separation. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 376C IPC | Sexual intercourse by a person in authority in specified circumstances. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 376D IPC | Gang rape. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 376DA IPC | Gang rape of a girl below 16 years. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 376DB IPC | Gang rape of a girl below 12 years. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 376E IPC | Punishment for specified repeat offenders. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 509 IPC | Words, gestures or acts intended to insult a woman's modesty. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
| Section 67B IT Act, 2000 | Specified offences involving electronic child sexual abuse material. | Referred to under Section 42 POCSO. |
CASE DETAILS
| Particular | Details |
|---|---|
| Case Title | Dipan Ghosh alias Dipon Ghosh v. The State of Assam & Anr. |
| Court | Gauhati High Court |
| Judgment Date | November 5, 2026 |
| Neutral Citation | 2026:GAU-AS:16273-DB |
| Bench | Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma |
| Case Number | Criminal Appeal No. 224/2025 |
| Counsel for Appellant | Advocate A. Ahmed |
| Counsel for State | Additional Public Prosecutor R.R. Kaushik |
| Counsel for Respondent No. 2 | Advocate J. Islam |
| Police Station | Patharkandi Police Station |
| FIR / Crime Number | 180/2013 |
| Sessions Case Number | 32/2016 |
| Trial Court Judgment | March 26, 2025 |
| Final Decision | Criminal appeal allowed; conviction set aside; accused acquitted of rape and POCSO charges; immediate release directed. |
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Failed Relationship Turned Into Rape Case: Criminal proceedings followed the man's refusal to marry the woman.
- Woman Contradicted Her Own Statements: Claimed she was 19 years old and later claimed she was 17.
- Consensual Sex Is Not Rape: Refusal to marry cannot criminalise a consensual relationship between adults.
- 20-Year Jail Sentence Overturned: Gauhati High Court rejected the rape and POCSO allegations and ordered the man's immediate release.
- 13 Years To Get Justice: A failed relationship cost a man his freedom and over a decade of legal battles.
Share Your Thoughts
Comments are moderated before publication.