Wife Accused Husband Of Cruelty, Yet Left Her Infant Child With Him To Live With Another Man: P&H High Court Questions Her Allegations
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana High Court questioned a married woman's allegations of cruelty against her husband after she left her infant child with him to enter a live-in relationship with another man.
The Single Bench of Justice Alok Jain was hearing a police protection petition filed by the woman and her unmarried companion.
The woman got married in 2025. She claimed that continuous physical and mental cruelty by her husband forced her to leave her matrimonial home in 2026.
She subsequently decided to enter into a live-in relationship with another man.
The couple approached the High Court, alleging threats from their relatives over their relationship.
However, the Court found that the petitioners failed to provide specific details about the date, time, or place of the alleged threats.
The Court also questioned why they had not personally approached the police if they genuinely feared for their safety.
Questioning the woman's decision to leave her child, aged below two years, with the very husband whom she had accused of cruelty, the Court referred to him sarcastically as “such a draconian man”.
The High Court stressed that the fundamental rights and welfare of the minor child could not be ignored.
Terming the plea a “fancy petition”, the Court expressed concern over the possible misuse of the legal process to cover up the nature of the petitioners' relationship.
The High Court further directed that any future complaints filed by the woman against her husband, in-laws or other relatives should be considered only if supported by substantial and reliable evidence of “impeccable veracity”.
The Court also directed that a copy of the order and the petition documents be sent to the private respondents.
The High Court indicated that the petition deserved exemplary costs. However, the petitioners' counsel sought permission to withdraw the plea. The Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissed the protection petition as withdrawn.
EXPLANATORY TABLE OF LAWS AND SECTIONS
| Law / Section | What It Means | Relevance In This Case |
|---|---|---|
| Article 21 of the Constitution | Protects the right to life and personal liberty. | Relevant to the couple's protection plea. |
| Article 226 of the Constitution | Empowers High Courts to issue writs and directions. | Relevant to petitions seeking police protection. |
| Principle of Child Welfare | Prioritises the safety, welfare and interests of minor children. | The Court considered the interests of the infant left with the father. |
| Abuse of Process of Law | Improper use of legal proceedings for an ulterior purpose. | The Court questioned the intention behind filing the protection petition. |
CASE DETAILS
| Particular | Details |
|---|---|
| Case Title | Wife & Live-In Partner v. Husband & Others |
| Court | Punjab and Haryana High Court |
| Bench | Justice Alok Jain |
| Bench Strength | Single Bench |
| Nature of Petition | Protection of life and liberty |
| Decision | Petition dismissed as withdrawn |
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Cruelty Allegations Questioned: Wife left her infant with the same husband she accused of cruelty.
- Father's Responsibility Recognised: The father continued to care for the minor child.
- Misuse of Legal Process: The High Court questioned the intention behind the protection petition.
- Safeguards Against Unsubstantiated Complaints: Future complaints against the husband and his family must be supported by credible material, as directed in this case.
- Child Welfare Matters: Personal relationships cannot overshadow parental responsibilities.
Share Your Thoughts
Comments are moderated before publication.