False 498A Case | "Husband Not Answering Wife's Phone Calls Does Not Amount To Cruelty": Calcutta High Court Quashes Case
WEST BENGAL: The Calcutta High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against a husband under Sections 498A and 34 IPC, holding that merely not answering his wife's phone calls does not amount to criminal cruelty.
Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta found the allegations against the husband vague and lacking the essential ingredients required to establish an offence.
The couple got married on 2 March 2017 and had a son. The wife subsequently accused her husband and in-laws of physical and mental torture, forcing her to perform household chores and denying her entry into her matrimonial home.
On 13 December 2020, the wife lodged an FIR against her husband, mother-in-law and sister-in-law. She also initiated separate proceedings under the Domestic Violence Act, 2005.
On 22 July 2021, the police filed a charge sheet against all three accused.
The husband submitted that he was pursuing his PhD in Haridwar when the complaint was registered. He further argued that he had been regularly paying ₹6,000 towards monthly maintenance and that his wife had made contradictory allegations.
Read Also:- Section 498a IPC | 498a Judgments | False Dowry Case | 498a Misuse
The criminal proceedings against his mother and sister had already been quashed by the High Court.
The State opposed the husband's quashing petition and argued that he should face trial. Meanwhile, the wife remained unrepresented despite being served notice.
After examining the complaint and case diary, the High Court found no specific details of physical or mental torture and no allegations of dowry demands against the husband.
The Court observed:
“A call left unreceived is, by itself, an omission and not an act of wilful conduct.”
The Court explained that ordinary matrimonial disagreements cannot automatically constitute criminal cruelty under Section 498A IPC.
The High Court also found no material establishing common intention under Section 34 IPC.
Holding that continuing the criminal proceedings against the husband would abuse the judicial process, the High Court quashed the proceedings, charge sheet, and related orders against him.
Read Also:- How To File 498A Or Section 85 BNS Quashing Petition Under Section 528 BNSS?
After nearly six years of battling criminal proceedings, the husband finally secured relief.
EXPLANATORY TABLE OF LAWS AND SECTIONS
| Law / Section | What It Means | Application In This Case |
|---|---|---|
| Section 498A IPC | Punishes criminal cruelty by a husband or his relatives. | Essential ingredients of cruelty were absent. |
| Section 498A Explanation (a) IPC | Wilful conduct likely to drive a woman to suicide or cause grave injury or danger to her health. | Unanswered phone calls did not satisfy this requirement. |
| Section 498A Explanation (b) IPC | Harassment connected with unlawful demands for property or valuable security. | No such demand was alleged against the husband. |
| Section 34 IPC | Criminal liability for acts committed with common intention. | No common intention was established or disclosed. |
| Section 401 CrPC | Revisional powers of the High Court. | Invoked to challenge criminal proceedings. |
| Section 482 CrPC | The High Court's inherent powers to prevent abuse of the legal process and secure justice. | Invoked for quashing criminal proceedings. |
| Section 161 CrPC | Examination of witnesses by police during investigation. | Witness statements were examined by the Court. |
| Section 442 BNSS | Revisional powers of the High Court. | Corresponding provision to Section 401 CrPC. |
| Section 528 BNSS | Preserves the High Court's inherent powers. | Corresponding provision to Section 482 CrPC. |
| Section 12 DV Act, 2005 | Application before a Magistrate seeking relief against domestic violence. | Separate domestic violence proceedings were initiated. |
| Article 227, Constitution of India | Supervisory jurisdiction of High Courts over subordinate courts and tribunals. | Invoked in the husband's petition. |
CASE DETAILS
| Particular | Details |
|---|---|
| Case Title | Tanmoy Roy v. The State of West Bengal & Anr. |
| Court | Calcutta High Court |
| Bench | Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta |
| Case Number | C.R.R. No. 409 of 2025 |
| Petitioner | Tanmoy Roy |
| Complainant | Paromita Roy (née Das) |
| FIR Number | 431 of 2020 |
| Police Station | Bagnan Police Station |
| Charge Sheet Number | 205/2021 |
| Trial Court Case | G.R. Case No. 2275 of 2020 |
| Trial Court | Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Uluberia, Howrah |
| Counsel For Petitioner | Mr. Sabir Ahmed, Mr. Partha Sarathi Sarkar, Mr. Dhiman Banerjee, Mr. Quazi Ezaz Ahmed |
| Counsel For State | Mr. Kallol Mondal (Public Prosecutor), Mr. Pawan Kumar Gupta, Mr. Arijit Bhusan Bagchi |
| Date Of Hearing | 22 September 2026 |
| Date Of Judgment | 16 November 2026 |
| Decision | Criminal proceedings quashed against the husband |
| Case Status | Criminal revision application allowed |
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Unanswered Phone Calls Are Not Cruelty: Not answering a wife’s phone calls cannot by itself justify a 498A case.
- Six Years of Injustice: Vague allegations forced a husband to fight years of criminal litigation.
- Entire Family Made to Suffer: Even his mother and sister were dragged into criminal proceedings.
- A Wife’s Allegations Are Not Proof: Men cannot be subjected to criminal prosecution without sufficient legal grounds.
- Justice Delivered, Lost Years Never Returned: The High Court quashed the case, but who will compensate the husband for his suffering?
Share Your Thoughts
Comments are moderated before publication.