False Case By Woman Exposed After P&H High Court Finds That Her Claim Of Her Father Being Bedridden Was A Lie, As He Had Died 8 Years Ago
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissed a woman’s transfer application after finding that she had made false claims about her father's health to obtain judicial relief, even though he had died seven to eight years earlier.
Justice Mandeep Pannu observed:
“Thus, the applicant has made a false averment regarding the illness and bedridden condition of her father who was already dead at the time of filing of the present transfer application, which constitutes concealment of a material fact having a direct bearing on the relief sought in the present application.”
The woman's brother-in-law had filed a civil suit for recovery of damages before the Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Phillaur.
She approached the High Court seeking the transfer of the case to Mukerian in Hoshiarpur district, claiming that she had to travel nearly 120 kilometres one way to attend court proceedings.
She further submitted that a maintenance petition under Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) against her husband was already pending in Mukerian.
The woman claimed that she was living with her parents, her father was poor, sick and bedridden, and she had no independent source of income. She argued that travelling alone to Phillaur would be extremely difficult for her.
However, her brother-in-law opposed the transfer application, stating that she was employed as a nurse and earned approximately Rs 30,000 per month.
He further submitted that the FIR lodged by the woman under Section 498A IPC (corresponding to Section 85 BNS) was pending only against her husband and that he had not been named as an accused.
He also argued that the maintenance proceedings had nothing to do with him and that the woman had concealed a crucial fact from the Court — her father had died seven to eight years earlier.
To support his argument, the brother-in-law produced the woman's wedding invitation card before the High Court.
The wedding card described the woman as “Shivani D/o Smt. Shakuntla Devi w/o Late Sh. Lakhwinder”.
The documentary evidence exposed the false claim made by the woman while seeking judicial relief.
Emphasising the importance of honesty in judicial proceedings, the High Court observed:
“It is well settled that a litigant seeking discretionary relief from the Court is required to approach the Court with clean hands and make a full and fair disclosure of all material facts. Suppression or misrepresentation of material facts disentitles a party from claiming such relief. In the present case, the applicant has not only suppressed a material fact but has also sought to seek advantage on the basis of a factually incorrect assertion.”
The Court further held:
“In view of the aforesaid circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion that the applicant is not entitled to the discretionary relief of transfer. Consequently, the present transfer application is dismissed.”
The ruling reinforces an important legal principle that judicial relief cannot be secured through false claims, concealment of facts or misrepresentation, irrespective of the gender of the litigant.
LAWS AND SECTIONS INVOLVED
| ACT / SECTION | LEGAL PROVISION | RELEVANCE TO THE CASE |
|---|---|---|
| Section 24 CPC | Power to transfer and withdraw civil proceedings | Woman sought transfer of the civil suit from Phillaur to Mukerian. |
| Section 144 BNSS, 2023 | Maintenance of wives, children and parents | Woman's maintenance petition against her husband was pending. |
| Section 498A IPC | Cruelty by husband or his relatives | Woman had lodged an FIR against her husband. |
| Section 85 BNS, 2023 | Cruelty by husband or his relatives | Corresponding provision to Section 498A IPC under the new criminal law. |
| Clean Hands Doctrine | Full and honest disclosure of material facts | Transfer plea was dismissed because of a false assertion. |
CASE DETAILS
| PARTICULARS | DETAILS |
|---|---|
| Case Title | Shivani v. Sunil Kumar |
| Court | Punjab and Haryana High Court |
| Bench | Hon’ble Justice Mandeep Pannu |
| Counsel for Applicant | Mr. Sunil Agnihotri, Advocate |
| Counsel for Respondent | Ms. Shruti Mandhotra, Advocate |
| Neutral Citation | Awaiting judgment PDF |
| Case Number | Not verified |
| Nature of Case | Transfer Application |
| Original Proceedings | Civil Suit for Recovery of Damages |
| State | Punjab |
| Date of News Report | 18 November 2026 |
| Final Verdict | Transfer Application Dismissed |
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Woman cited her dead father's illness to seek judicial relief.
- Wedding invitation card exposed her false claim.
- Brother-in-law had to produce evidence to counter her claims.
- High Court rejected her transfer application.
- Gender cannot be a licence to mislead courts.
Share Your Thoughts
Comments are moderated before publication.