Live-in Relationships Attracts 498A Charges Against Men For Cruelty? Orissa High Court Answers
CUTTACK: The Orissa High Court has held that a long-term live-in relationship resembling marriage can attract Section 498A IPC cruelty charges, even without a legally valid marriage.
In a judgment, Justice R.K. Pattanaik partly allowed a man's criminal revision petition challenging the rejection of his discharge application.
The case began with an FIR registered at Koraput Town Police Station on March 13, 2016, under Sections 498A, 313, 323 and 506 IPC.
The complainant, a widow with a 10-year-old daughter, alleged that she developed a physical relationship with the man and subsequently married him at a temple on December 12, 2011.
She claimed that they lived together for nearly four to five years, during which she allegedly faced physical assault, abuse and cruelty before being forced to leave.
The man was arrested on March 19, 2016, and later released on bail.
Read Also:- How Men Can Protect Themselves In Live-In Relationships: Complete Legal Guide 2026
After the police filed a chargesheet, he sought discharge under Section 227 CrPC, arguing that no valid marriage existed and that the allegations lacked sufficient supporting evidence.
On November 15, 2023, the Additional Sessions Judge-cum-Special Judge, Koraput, rejected his discharge application.
The man challenged this order before the High Court, claiming that he had been falsely implicated and that no medical evidence supported the allegations of miscarriage.
The High Court examined the Supreme Court's ruling in Dr Lokesh B.H. v. State of Karnataka (2026 INSC 784), which recognised that Section 498A IPC may apply to long-term live-in relationships having the essential characteristics of marriage.
The Court clarified that merely ending a live-in relationship does not automatically amount to criminal cruelty. The relationship and alleged conduct must satisfy the legal requirements of Section 498A IPC.
While examining the man's argument that no valid marriage existed, the Court observed:
βAccepting the version of the petitioner at the stage of charge with a plea that there has been no valid marriage is not permissible under law.β
The High Court held that the woman's allegations of living together as spouses required examination during trial.
However, the Court took a different view regarding the Section 313 IPC charge of causing miscarriage without the woman's consent.
It found that the prosecution had not produced medical reports, supporting documents or independent evidence connecting the alleged miscarriage to the accused.
The Court observed:
βNo corroborative medical evidence on miscarriage is on record.β
It further stated:
βJust a casual claim with an allegation of miscarriage is not sufficient to go for a trial for an offence of miscarriage when there is no any evidence except an uncorroborated claim of the victim.β
Accordingly, the High Court discharged the man from the Section 313 IPC charge, holding that an uncorroborated allegation was insufficient to justify a criminal trial for such a serious offence.
However, the Court found sufficient prima facie material to continue the trial under Sections 498A, 323 and 506 IPC.
The High Court partly allowed the man's criminal revision petition and modified the trial court's order dated November 15, 2023.
EXPLANATORY TABLE OF LAWS AND SECTIONS
| Law / Section | What It Means | Application In This Case |
|---|---|---|
| Section 498A IPC | Punishes cruelty by a husband or his relatives. | Trial permitted despite disputed marriage. |
| Section 313 IPC | Punishes causing miscarriage without the woman's consent. | Man discharged due to insufficient supporting evidence. |
| Section 323 IPC | Punishment for voluntarily causing hurt. | Trial allowed to continue. |
| Section 506 IPC | Punishment for criminal intimidation. | Charge retained for trial. |
| Section 227 CrPC | Allows discharge when sufficient grounds for proceeding are absent. | Man sought discharge from criminal charges. |
| Sections 397 and 401 CrPC | Provide revisional powers to examine lower court orders. | High Court partly allowed the criminal revision. |
| Sections 161 and 164 CrPC | Concern statements recorded during investigation and before a Magistrate, respectively. | Statements considered while examining the prosecution material. |
| Section 91 CrPC | Enables courts or police officers to require production of documents or things. | Man's earlier document-production application was rejected. |
| Section 482 CrPC | Preserves the High Court's inherent powers. | Discussed while examining earlier judgments. |
| Section 494 IPC | Punishes bigamy where statutory conditions are met. | Discussed through an earlier Supreme Court decision. |
| Section 27(b) NDPS Act | Punishes specified consumption of narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances. | Mentioned in a precedent concerning discharge. |
CASE DETAILS
| Particular | Details |
|---|---|
| Case Title | Hari Krushna Mahanty v. State of Odisha |
| Court | Orissa High Court, Cuttack |
| Bench | Justice R.K. Pattanaik |
| Judgment Authored By | Justice R.K. Pattanaik |
| Case Number | CRLREV No. 212 of 2024 |
| CNR | ODHC010271992024 |
| Petitioner's Counsel | Senior Advocate Dharanidhar Nayak and Advocate A. Bhuyan |
| State's Counsel | Mr S.K. Brahma, Additional Standing Counsel |
| Police Station | Koraput Town Police Station |
| FIR Number | P.S. Case No. 48 of 2016 |
| Trial Court | Additional Sessions Judge-cum-Special Judge, Koraput |
| Original Case | C.T. Case No. 07 of 2023 |
| Trial Court Order | November 15, 2023 |
| Final Decision | Revision partly allowed; Section 313 IPC charge dropped; trial to continue for remaining offences. |
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- 498A Beyond Marriage: Even without a legally valid marriage, a man can face cruelty charges in a marriage-like live-in relationship.
- Serious Charge Against Man Dropped: High Court rejected the miscarriage charge due to insufficient evidence.
- Allegations Alone Are Not Evidence: An uncorroborated miscarriage claim cannot force a man to face trial for such a serious offence.
- 498A Trial Still Continues: Despite securing partial relief, the man must continue defending himself against cruelty and other charges.
- Men Deserve Justice, Not Presumed Guilt: Serious accusations demand proper evidence. An allegation must never become a punishment in itself.
Share Your Thoughts
Comments are moderated before publication.