High Court

False Promise To Marry Case| Woman Accuses Railway Employee Of Rape To Extort ₹20 Lakh From Him? MP High Court Grants Him Anticipatory Bail

A woman accused a railway employee of rape on a false promise of marriage, but the MP High Court found a possible ₹20 lakh extortion motive amid a child custody dispute. What led the Court to grant him anticipatory bail under Section 69 BNS?

False Promise To Marry Case| Woman Accuses Railway Employee Of Rape To Extort ₹20 Lakh From Him? MP High Court Grants Him Anticipatory Bail
High Court NEWS DESK

False Promise To Marry Case| Woman Accuses Railway Employee Of Rape To Extort ₹20 Lakh From Him? MP High Court Grants Him Anticipatory Bail

NEWS DESK

Curated by NEWS DESK

Editorial Desk

MADHYA PRADESH: The Madhya Pradesh High Court has granted anticipatory bail to a railway employee accused of sexual relations on a false promise of marriage, after examining the couple's long-standing relationship and an alleged demand of ₹20 lakh connected with their daughter's custody.

Justice Pradeep Mittal granted relief on November 17, 2026, in a case registered at Ashoka Garden Police Station, Bhopal, under Sections 69, 115(2) and 351(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).

The woman alleged that the accused established physical relations with her by promising marriage but later refused to marry her. She also accused him of physical assault and criminal intimidation.

Appearing for the accused, advocate Rajesh Nema submitted that the 37-year-old complainant had married another man in 2011 and obtained a divorce in 2024. Meanwhile, the accused married another woman in December 2019.

Read Also:- Anticipatory Bail Application Format Under Section 482 BNSS: PDF & Affidavit

According to the defence, their relationship began in November 2018 and continued despite their respective marriages. They had a daughter on October 2, 2021, whose birth certificate identified the accused as her father.

Disputes subsequently arose over the child's upbringing and custody. The accused approached the Family Court in Bhopal seeking custody under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956.

While examining the anticipatory bail application, the High Court considered the FIR, the woman's statements recorded at a One Stop Centre in June 2026 and the pending family court proceedings.

The court observed:

"These documents are relevant circumstances which cannot be altogether ignored while considering the prayer for anticipatory bail,"

The High Court also noted that the parties were involved in a dispute concerning their daughter's custody and upbringing.

However, it clarified that the allegations required examination during investigation and trial:

"Whether the allegations regarding a false promise of marriage, coercion or threats are ultimately established is a matter to be examined during investigation and trial. At this stage, no conclusive opinion on these aspects is warranted,"

The court emphasised that the circumstances of a relationship between consenting adults must be examined to determine whether consent was voluntary or obtained through a false promise of marriage made without any intention of fulfilling it.

Importantly, the woman was already married when the relationship began and continued her association with the accused even after his marriage to another woman.

The High Court considered these circumstances indicative of a consensual relationship based on mutual understanding.

It further observed that the allegations concerning breach of a marriage promise did not appear sustainable at the bail stage. The complaint also appeared to involve an ulterior motive of extracting ₹20 lakh from the accused in the name of their daughter.

Considering these circumstances, the High Court granted anticipatory bail to the accused. The court expressly clarified that its observations were limited to deciding the bail application and would not influence the investigation or trial.

EXPLANATORY TABLE OF LAWS AND SECTIONS

Law / SectionLegal provisionRelevance to this case
Section 69 BNS, 2023Sexual intercourse by deceitful means or a promise to marry made without intention to fulfil it; punishment up to 10 years and finePrincipal allegation against the accused
Section 115(2) BNSPunishment for voluntarily causing hurt; up to one year, ₹10,000 fine, or bothWoman alleged physical assault
Section 351(2) BNSPunishment for criminal intimidation; up to two years, fine, or bothWoman alleged threats
Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956Governs specified aspects of guardianship of Hindu minorsAccused approached Family Court seeking custody of his daughter
Section 482 BNSS, 2023Provision for anticipatory bailRelevant procedural provision for pre-arrest protection; the report does not expressly identify the section used in the application

CASE DETAILS

ParticularDetails
Case TitleRailway Employee vs. State of Madhya Pradesh
CourtMadhya Pradesh High Court
BenchJustice Pradeep Mittal, Single Bench
Order date17 November 2026
Counsel for AccusedAdvocate Rajesh Nema
Police stationAshoka Garden, Bhopal
AccusedRailway employee
Complainant37-year-old woman
OutcomeAnticipatory bail granted

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • False Promise of Marriage: A failed relationship does not automatically establish an offence under Section 69 BNS.
  • Consensual Relationship: The High Court considered the parties' long relationship and knowledge of each other's marriages.
  • ₹20 Lakh Demand: The Court noted a possible ulterior motive of extracting money from the accused amid a child custody dispute.
  • Men's Right to Liberty: Serious allegations alone do not justify automatic arrest. The accused secured anticipatory bail.
  • Allegations Are Not Proof: The Court granted bail without deciding guilt, reinforcing that men deserve legal protection and a fair trial.

Share

NEWS DESK

NEWS DESK

Legal news and court developments curated by the Shonee Kapoor editorial desk.

Share Your Thoughts

Comments are moderated before publication.