Cruelty Judgements

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Cold indifference like not visiting the hospitalized husband amounts to cruelty.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Section 13(1)(ia) –– Cruelty — Acts of wife proving her incorrigible conduct –– Amounts to cruelty towards her husband –– Wife can’t be allowed to take advantage of her own wrong.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Section 13(1)(ia) and 20(2) — Husband’s petition for divorce on ground of wife’s cruelty granted by Trial Court — Appeal against by wife — Appellate Court finding wife leaving matrimonial home 12 days after marriage with jwellery and dowry articles — Thereafter followed series of offensive and defensives — Evidence and pleadings of wife’s cruelty.

PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Section 13 — Marriage dissolved by decree of divorce on ground of desertion and cruelty — Appeal by wife — Husband a widower having a son from first wife — Appeared that wife is not ablet to reconcile that she has to look after the son from first wife — Presence of son causing heart burning — Document of return of dowry executed in presence of respectables — Wife not willing to return to matrimonial house — Decree of divorce affirmed.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Section 13(1)(ia) — Mental Cruelty — Sexual deprivation by wife — Non-consummation of marriage on part of appellant- wife — Respondent-husband, in his evidence has narrated in detail incidents of alleged cruelty suffered by him — Appellant admits that marriage was not consummated — Not allowing a spouse for a long time to have sexual intercourse by his or her partner without sufficient reason, itself amounts mental cruelty to such spouse — No ground to interfere with decree of divorce passed by High Court on ground of cruelty.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Family Courts Act, 1984 — Section 19 — Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 — Section 13 — Divorce — Cruelty — Appellant married and two children were born out of wedlock — Incidents of cruelty proved by PW 1 which are corroborated from statement of PWs 3 and 4 — Cruelty includes insulting husband and other members of his family in presence of guests — Foul language also used against husband and in-laws — Husband was not allowed to talk to his children on phone when he was in Holland — Reassessment of evidence on record proves case for divorce on ground of cruelty — Trial Court’s judgment upheld — No force in appeal.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Divorce on ground of cruelty – Appeal – Appealant wife misbehaved not only with husband and in-laws but also with guests and visitors – Appealant also filed criminal cases against respondent husband. Appeal dismissed.

  Court:HIGH COURT OF DELHI Bench: JUSTICE S. Muralidhar Darshana Devi Vs. Anil Kumar Saini On 13 June 2007 Law Point: Section 13(1)(ia) — Cruelty — Prima facie case made out — Trial Court rightly held respondent wife along with her father caused mental cruelty upon petitioner husband in deserting his matrimonial home, after birth of child and by involving

Court:HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN
Involvement of Appellant wife in a murder case amounts to cruelty and Family Court had rightly granted decree of divorce.

Court:ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Cruelty: What amounts to : False, scandalous, malicious, baseless and unproved allegations made by one spouse amounts to cruelty : Cruelty may consist of single act or series of acts.

Court:RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Section 13 — Cruelty : Wife Practised Cruelty by Her Own Misbehaviour and by Making False Allegations Against Her Husband About His Having Illicit Relations with His Brother’s Wife : Family Court Justified in Passing Decree of Dissolution of Marriage.

Court:RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Wife Refused to Cook Food and Insulted Husband in Presence of his Relations : She does not Want to Live with Husband : Decree of Divorce Confirmed.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Petition by husband for decree of divorce — Appellant writing letter to respondent stating that he was rascal and his mother, sister and brother’s wife had given birth to bastards — She disowned her own writings — She also had pungent tongue — Levelling false allegations could reasonably cause mental cruelty to respondent giving him justifiable ground for divorce.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Cruelty — Defamatory complaints to employer or other authorities constitute worse type of cruelty — Cruelty consists not in conduct complained of but in its impact upon spouse.

Court:ANDHRA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Cruelty : Sufficient Material Against Wife : Marriage Irretrievably Broken Down — Behaviour of respondent-wife such that it is impossible for petitioner-husband to share marital life with her — Even in her evidence she admitted that she gave police complaints against petitioner and sent petitions against him to High Court only with a view to create problems to petitioner —Respondent-wife is bent upon wreaking vengeance against petitioner — Cumulative effect — Marital relationship of parties irretrievably broken down.

Court:CALCUTTA HIGH COURT
Husband’s petition for divorce on ground of wife’s cruelty — Wife frequently departing from matrimonial home without permission putting husband in constant fear and anxiety by leaving suicidal notes — Lodging complaint in police against husband and her in-laws — Writing, insulting and offensive letters to office of husband — Facts prove that wife treated the husband with cruelty.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Question of condonation of cruelty of wife by husband — Husband specifying Acts of cruelty — Wife neither specifying which of the various acts of cruelty was condoned and when.

Court: MADHYA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Lodging of false criminal report by wife against her husband & his family — Leading to arrest of husband & harassment of his family — Refusal by wife to fulfill sexual desire of her husband & defaming husband to be impotent — Amounts cruelty to husband — Marriage deserves to be dissolved.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Section 13(1)(ib) — Wife’s desertion since 28.9.79 — Wife leaving matrimonial home as her own — Allegation that she was driven out not believable — Whether husband is also entitled to decree of divorce on ground of desertion by wife ? (Yes).

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Charges of immorality levelled by wife against husband were reckless and entirely baseless. Further, wife’s own evidence before Court led credence to husband’s case that wife insulted and humiliated him by false accusations and injurious reproaches. Wife’s charges were deliberate, willful, injurious and persistent – Thus, it was clear that re-establishment of matrimonial relationship was not possible. Decree of divorce in favour of husband on ground of cruelty.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Husband’s petition for dissolution of Marriage owing to wife’s cruelty — Wife asking husband to live separately due to ill-treatment of her mother-in-law — Wife writing letters to husband threatening him to insult in his office and in front of his superiors that be would not forget it for the rest of his life — Intemperate language used — Referring to a husband as the incarnation of “Havana” — Calling him a person of mean mentality and cheap character — Making unsubstantiated allegations regarding illicit relationship. Wife guilty of the matrimonial offence of cruelty.

Court: GAUHATI HIGH COURT
Wife neither having any tolerant attitude nor ready to make even a small sacrifice. Misbehavior of wife at public places and resiling from settlement. Cruelty of wife established.

Court: HIMACHAL PRADESH HIGH COURT
Cruelty : Legal : False Allegations of Harassment, Physical Assault, Not Providing Maintenance : Amounts to Cruelty — Allegations made by Wife against Husband in application are unfounded, baseless and false — Amounts to legal cruelty.

Court:ANDHRA PRADESH HIGH COURT
On complaint lodged by wife, husband arrested and sent to judicial custody — Kept under suspension by his employer — Matter reached point of no return — Any amount of persuasion to keep matrimonial home in good stead is of no use — Marriage dissolved by granting decree of divorce.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Indifferent behaviour with the husband and his relations––Trying to jump from balcony on the event of marriage in family––Not permitting normal sex to respondent—Indifference to the ailing father-in-law––Cruelty.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Divorce — Cruelty by wife — Allegation of illicit relationship with his sister-in-law and niece of respondent itself constitutes cruelty — Respondent was subjected to cruelty after settlement agreement and it continued till impugned judgment was passed — Decree for divorce affirmed.

Court: Gauhati High Court
Wife lodged false criminal proceeding and threatened to commit suicide. Leveling such serious allegations, in absence of any proof thereof, itself amounts to cruelty. Divorce granted on ground of cruelty.

Court:ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Divorce on ground of cruelty – Appeal – Cruelty includes not only physical cruelty but also mental cruelty. Sufficient material on record to prove that wife had treated husband with mental cruelty and it had become impossible for husband to live with wife.

Court: UTTARAKHAND HIGH COURT
Divorce, Cruelty, Desertion — Husband and wife not living together. Testimony of husband reliable. Cruelty committed by wife fully proved on record. Divorce granted on ground of cruelty.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
By wife’s abnormal behaviour impossible for Husband to reside with Wife — Wife failed to discharge her marital obligations — Treated Husband with mental cruelty. Decree of Divorce granted.

Court: UTTARAKHAND HIGH COURT
Wife made no attempt to come back to her husband’s house nor tried to contact him over phone — Husband has sufficiently proved on record that he was subjected to cruelty by wife and entitled to divorce.

Court:BOMBAY HIGH COURT
Sufficient proof of allegation of cruelty by husband on part of wife — No reason to refuse decree of divorce.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Wife made allegations on her sister-in-law to create situation where relationship between parties comes to worst. Wife was guilty of inflicting cruelty upon Husband including mental cruelty of worst kind. Marriage dissolved.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Cruelty — Desertion — Appellant-wife failed to lead cogent evidence to establish respondent-husband created such circumstances that it was not possible for her to reside in matrimonial home — Wife made reckless allegations against husband of being womanizer and corrupt — It would have caused such pain and suffering to respondent as to lead to apprehension that it would not be conducive to his physical and mental well-being to live with wife. Marriage dissolved.

Court:ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Mental and Physical Cruelty : Allegations of having illicit relationship and extra marital affairs made by wife against husband amounted to cruelty : Various criminal proceedings initiated against husband found to be false and final report submitted. Husband entitled to divorce under Section 13(1)(ia) of Act.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Mental Cruelty — Wife taunted Husband for not being able to satiate her sexual desire on account of his being heavy weight — Calling of names and hurling of abuses. Incidents are grave and weighty matrimonial offences by wife — Events not relating to normal wear and tear of a marriage.

Court:Delhi High Court
Denial of sexual intercourse after marriage — Refusal to perform customary rituals — Sex is the foundation of marriage and marriage without sex is an anathema — Wilful denial of sexual intercourse without reasonable cause would amount to cruelty.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Threat to commit suicide by consuming acid — By said act, wife alleged to be pregnant created fear in the mind of husband and his family. Fear in the mind of husband and his family cannot be called unfounded. Acts of wife amount to mental cruelty.

Court:RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Totally false and baseless allegation leveled against Husband by Wife about having illicit relations with his Bhabhi, clearly tantamounts to cruelty on her part to respondent-husband — Respondent-husband entitled to decree of divorce on this ground.

Court: DELHI HIGH COURT
Illicit relations — Baseless allegations by wife — Wife suffering from delusion and continuously under treatment — Appellant-wife living with her parents most of the time after her marriage and she had been under treatment — False and baseless allegations made by appellant-wife against her husband about illicit relations remain unproved — Such type of aspersions on character of respondent-husband even or on his ‘Bhabhi’ is worst form of cruelty.

Court:CALCUTTA HIGH COURT
Unfounded allegations against husband not proved by wife — Holy relationship of brother and sister maligned by wife that it pricks to conscience of Court to accept that wife is guilty of treating Husband with mental cruelty.

Court:UTTARANCHAL HIGH COURT>
Husband successfully proved he was treated with cruelty by his wife, by her acts of hurling abuses at him and beating members of his family : Alleged acts of violence on part of wife, committed by her, get corroborated from medical injury report : Allegations made by wife as to harassment on account of dowry, not established on record. Divorce granted.

Court: BOMBAY HIGH COURT
Allegations made by wife baseless and false and constituted cruelty : Learned Judge right in granting decree of divorce on that ground and rejecting her petition for maintenance under Section 18 of Hindu Marriage Act.

Court:BOMBAY HIGH COURT
Marriage between parties irretrievably broken down — Parties cannot be reasonably expected to live together — Wife has made wild unsubstantiated allegations against husband — Applicant-husband subjected to mental cruelty at the hands of respondent-wife — Family Court rightly allowed petition of husband for dissolution of marriage under Section 10(1)(x) of Act on ground of cruelty.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Constant persuasion by wife for getting separated from family members of husband — Wife wanted husband to leave his parents — Persistent effort of respondent-wife to constrain the appellant-husband to be separated from family would be torturous for husband.

Court: MADHYA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Cruelty, Adultery : Wife made scandalous statement against appellant/husband about his illicit relation with his elder brother’s wife : Trial Court wrongly held that allegations made by respondent/wife in her written statement and her deposition on oath cannot be taken into consideration while deciding this petition : Trial Court erred in directing husband to file separate petition for getting required relief on basis of allegations made by wife : Approach of Court contrary to settled principles of law which lay down Court’s power to take into consideration events subsequent to filing of petition.

Court: DELHI HIGH COURT
Mental Cruelty — Illicit relationship — Threat to commit suicide — Appellant-husband suggested divorce by mutual consent in the backdrop of respondent-wife’s illicit relationship, but she preferred not to even respond to that suggestion — Their daughter is being brought up by her father and grandmother for last 4 years — Version of appellant-husband that telephonically respondent-wife communicated her intention to live with her lover only — Accusations against wife specific as well the efforts made by husband to find peaceful solution to problem — Appellant-husband knows if wife attempts to commit suicide or commit suicide he and his entire family would be entangled in criminal case — Legal consequences that may ensue on threat being extended by wife to commit suicide or attempted suicide, impact on his life is to the extent that his entire family starts living under shadow of fear of being implicated in case under Sections 498A, 306, 304B, IPC — Threat to commit suicide constitutes Cruelty for purpose of Section 13(1)(ia) of Act — Decree of divorce granted in favour of appellant-husband.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Lodging false criminal case — Contracting second marriage — Respondent-wife lodged false criminal case against appellant-husband and his family — No material to frame charges against appellant and his family members — They were acquitted — Respondent-wife married one and living happily with him — Contracting second marriage during subsistence of first marriage would also amount to cruelty — Appellant-husband established that respondent wife is guilty of cruelty and entitled to get decree of divorce.

Court: RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Cruelty — Character assassination — According to husband, wife was having illicit relations with a distant relative before marriage and that persisted thereafter — Parties living separately for more than 14 years — Wild allegations made by wife against husband in reply to petition were sufficient to cause mental agony to husband — It is nothing than to injure reputation which amounts to mental cruelty — There is irretrievable breakdown of marriage of parties considering serious allegations made by wife throwing mud on the character of husband that her real sister has walked into life of her husband, which was not even prima facie established — It is difficult for both of them to live together as a happily married couple —Divorce granted.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Appellant wife failed to substantiate allegations leveled against respondent-husband even on yardstick of preponderance of evidence — Allegations of such a nature that would have lowered image of respondent in eyes of his superiors, subordinates and peers — This act would certainly constitute cruelty.

Court: DELHI HIGH COURT
False accusation by wife — Acts of cruelty included constant threat by wife to have the husband arrested which caused stress to the husband and his family with the result that it was not possible for him to continue with the marriage — False accusations had adversely affected mind and health of husband causing great embarrassment to him and his family leading them to be looked down upon by relatives, friends and neighbours. Family Court fully justified in dissolving the marriage of parties by decree of divorce.

Court:RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Cruelty — Desertion — Adultery — Grounds well established by Husband — Divorce decree sustained. Not fit case of making efforts through mediation for restoration of matrimonial home.

Court:Supreme Court of India
Wife living separately and filing cases against Husband which cannot be substantiated. Divorce Decreed.

Court:HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Divorce on the ground of desertion and cruelty – Parties lived together for 7 months and litigating for 25 years – Husband employed as judicial officer and wife working under government – Wife making various complaints in respect of her husband – An article also published in the newspaper on the basis of interview of wife – Such conduct caused mental agony to the husband – Decree of divorce affirmed.

Court: HIMACHAL PRADESH HIGH COURT
Filing of false complaints and threatening the Husband amount to acts of cruelty. Wife used to leave the matrimonial home at her own will, which amounts to desertion. Decree of divorce granted to Husband.

Court: PUNJAB & HARYANA HIGH COURT
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 — Sec. 13(1)(ia) — Cruelty — Meaning of Cruelty — Conduct of appellant in matrimonial home — Her threats and attempts to commit suicide — Act of lodging false complaint against her husband — Relations u/Secs. 498-A/34, I.P.C., resulting in acquittal — Are incidents of appellant’s cruel behaviour towards respondent — Making it impossible for respondent to live peacefully with her in conjugal home — Trial Court not fallen into error in holding appellant guilty of offence of cruelty & granting decree of divorce in favour of respondent — Whether correct ? — (Yes).

Court:UTTARAKHAND HIGH COURT
Cruelty, Desertion — Both grounds proved by respondent — False allegation of adultery against husband or wife is mental cruelty and is ground for divorce — Vague allegations made to defame by petitioner amounts to cruelty — Respondent wife failed to implead as party and prove her allegation of adultery against petitioner — Non-compliance of Rule 13 of Divorce Rules — From statement of appellant it is clear there was no relationship between parties as husband and wife even when they were not resided under single roof since April 2001 — Appellant deserted respondent and did not cohabit with him — Respondent proved both grounds for divorce, i.e., cruelty and desertion — Petition rightly allowed by Trial Court for decree of divorce.

Court:Delhi High Court
Act of Wife in filing false complaint case and getting her Husband and other in-laws arrested clearly amounts to cruelty. Decree of divorce passed.

Court: ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Appellant-wife has treated respondent with mental cruelty and permanently deserted respondent-husband in terms of Section 13(1)(ia), (ib) of Act. Lodging of FIR and spate of complaints with all sorts of allegations by wife against husband is indicative of fact that there was no desire on part of wife to continue marital relation with husband. Divorce granted.

Court:PATNA HIGH COURT
In retaliation to divorce case criminal case filed by Wife Conduct of appellant negates her claim. Husband able to prove grounds of cruelty.

Court:PATNA HIGH COURT
Act of Wife in neither willing to return to matrimonial home nor allowing peaceful divorce to petitioner, proves beyond any doubt that there is no chance of marriage being retrieved and continuance of such marriage would itself amount to cruelty.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Wife’s total indifference and neglect during illness of husband. Parties have no feelings and emotions towards each other, Impossible to preserve or save marriage.

Court:Delhi High Court
Sexless marriage, Wife made false complaints to husband’s boss, hence Divorce on mental cruelty.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Behaviour of wife established that she deliberately stayed away from marital home and intentionally caused mental agony by putting husband and his family to go through criminal litigation .The decree of divorce granted by the High Court deserves to be affirmed singularly on the ground of mental cruelty.

Court:ANDHRA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Act of Writing letter to third party amounts to publishing and publication about impotency of husband creating mental agony and anguish to Husband, which is mental cruelty. Decree for divorce passed.

Court:Supreme Court of India
Staying together under the same roof is no pre-condition of mental cruelty. Spouse can cause mental cruelty by her conduct even while she is not staying under the same roof.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Wife misused her right and subjected Husband to mental cruelty. She backed out of compromise and after obtaining lump sum amount filed divorce petition. She also filed criminal cases against respondent and his family under Sections 406, 498A, IPC. Wife left no stone unturned to make life of Husband miserable. Trial Court rightly granted decree of divorce in favour of respondent-husband.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
False allegations by wife of illicit relationship of Husband were made and she had refused to consummate the marriage with husband. Mental cruelty caused to husband. Wife also abandoned the marital relationship without any reason amounting to desertion.

Court:ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Conduct of wife cruel enough to give rise to suspicions of husband as to fidelity of wife.Differences between parties so deep rooted ruling out any possibility of reconciliation. Divorce granted as requested by Husband.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Impounding of passport of Father in Law who has to return is cruelty. Passport to be returned on execution of bond.

Court: RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Settlement and Understanding Between Spouses to Amicably Live Together with Harmony: Permission to Compound Offence Granted.

Court:Patna High Court
Wife filed 498A and made various scandalous allegations, Divorce on cruelty.

Court:Supreme Court of India
Clear manifestations of wife suspecting husband’s fidelity, character and reputation. Constant nagging on various aspects certainly amounted to causing indelible mental agony and amount to cruelty. Divorce granted.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Refusal to participate in proceedings for divorce and forcing Husband to stay in a dead marriage would itself constitute mental cruelty. There is no likelihood of appellant and respondent living together and for all practical purposes there is irretrievable breakdown of marriage.

Court:RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Filing of false complaint under Section 498A, IPC by Wife is sufficient ground to constitute matrimonial cruelty

Court:HIMACHAL PRADESH HIGH COURT
Presumption as to abetment of suicide by married woman is cruelty. It has to be established that wife was subjected to cruelty as ingrained in Section 498A, IPC.

Court:ANDHRA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Threat to put life to an end, Removing of Mangalsutram from her neck, Beatings to the child, Frequent desertion of Husband amounts to cruelty.

Court:BOMBAY HIGH COURT
Day-to-day behaviour of wife made life of petitioner intolerable and he left his own matrimonial home to stay with his own relatives Husband not given properly cooked food. He was forced to wash his own clothes and two children tutored by Wife to turn against Husband. Irretrievable breakdown of marriage on account of cruelty inflicted by wife on husband. Husband had no conjugal relations with wife. Wife not filed written statement and was absent on all dates except one date. Marriage dissolved by decree of divorce.

Court:ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Intention to be cruel not essential element : In marital matters, feelings and attitudes of minds are material.

Court:MADRAS HIGH COURT
Husband suffered mental agony and pain. Entitled to divorce.

Court:HIMACHAL PRADESH HIGH COURT
False case registered against Husband and his family members only to settle personal scores. Attitude of appellant wife in leaving matrimonial home at her sweet will and pleasure and showing disrespectful attitude to husband and family members, without any justifiable cause is cruelty towards Husband. Parties living apart for 6-7 years, which is admitted and proved on record — Divorce granted.

Court: BOMBAY HIGH COURT
Family Court Right in Concluding that Husband made out Case for Divorce on Ground of Cruelty and he is Entitled to Decree of Divorce.

Court:PUNJAB & HARYANA HIGH COURT
Offensive language — Addressed the husband as “Fauji Gadha or Fauji Tatoo” — Would not be acceptable to any self-respecting husband — Cruelty made out.

Court:KARNATAKA HIGH COURT
Spouse, well educated, responsible, well natured in general sense, abusing the other spouse, physically and mentally, humiliating, using filthy language in front of family members, relatives and mistaking for unintentional deeds. This would amount to cruelty.

Court:MADHYA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Wife guilty of making false, baseless and dirty allegations against her husband concerning his character. Husband bound to suffer mental agony and embarrassment living jointly with his parents and family members : Wife living separately from last more than 12 years. No valid and sufficient reason of defendant of living separately from her husband : Circumstances sufficient to hold Wife guilty of matrimonial offence of mental cruelty. Husband deserves dissolution of marriage by decree of divorce.

Court:CALCUTTA HIGH COURT
Forceful entry in house of Husband by Wife with help of local people during pendency of divorce proceedings, amounts of cruelty.

Court: MADHYA PRADESH HIGH COURT
False prosecution of Husband and his family members. Appellant and his family members including female family members of appellant had to face agony of trial of criminal case for long 7 years. They had to suffer humiliation during this period and ultimately charges levelled against them could not be substantiated.

Court:BOMBAY HIGH COURT
False, frivolous and unsubstantiated allegations against husband of having illicit relations with his sisters — No contemporaneous evidence produced by wife to corroborate her version — It was clearly an attempt to sully reputation not only of respondent-husband but also of two sisters who were in profession of Medicine and Law respectively — That by itself is a good and germane ground to dissolve marriage between parties and to grant decree of divorce.

Court:MADHYA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Wife behaving cruelly with Husband and his family members and she left matrimonial house and living separately without any just and proper cause. She has deserted respondent for continuous period of not less than two years. Husband entitled to decree of divorce.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Husband Deprived of Normal Cohabitation and Suffered Social Embarrassment Due to Behaviour of Wife. Conduct of Wife in Approaching Police Complaining against Her Husband and His Parents and Taking False Plea that She Conceived But there was Miscarriage, Caused Sense of Mental Depression and amounts to Mental Cruelty to Husband.

Court:ORISSA HIGH COURT
Wife Voluntarily Deprived Her Husband of Her Society and Cohabitation for Years, Which Amounts to Mental Cruelty. Husband can definitely be said to be under strain of wilful separation for years and complete denial of conjugal relationship.

Court:PUNJAB & HARYANA HIGH COURT
Cruelty — To be determined on consideration of various factors i.e. social status, background, custom & tradition, etc. The Court should determine that relationship between the parties has deteriorated to such an extent that it is impossible to live together without mental agony — Need not be of such a character as to cause danger to life or health.

Court:KARNATAKA HIGH COURT
Conduct of Wife in prosecuting Husband while at same time seeking restitution of conjugal rights shows lack of self-control driving Wife to restrain from cohabitation. Wife persisently indulging in vicious allegations, unmindful of their impact. Husband cannot be found at fault with and his conduct cannot fall within expression “his own wrong”.

Court:RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Evidence Produced by Wife not Sufficient to Disprove Charge of Cruelty and Adultery Levelled against Her : She made Unsuccessful Attempt to Establish that her Husband had Illicit Relations and Wanted to Marry Another Lady. Husband Proved Successfully his Apprehension that it will be Harmful for him to Live with Wife because of her Conduct that Caused Disgrace to him.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
No strait jacket formula of what is cruelty. Single or even isolated acts of grave severity can constitute cruelty. However, on other hand whole body of evidence may not measure upto required standard to constitute cruelty.

Court: MADRAS HIGH COURT
Meaning of Cruelty — No specific set of facts which could be taken as one which would constitute cruelty — Gravity, intensity and seriousness of acts of parties should necessarily be considered.

Court:Supreme Court of India
Appellant was subjected to serious traumatic experience because of non-cooperation and hostile attitude of respondent, which can safely be termed as ‘cruelty’. Decree of dissolution of marriage granted.

Court:CALCUTTA HIGH COURT
Cruel behaviour of spouse although is a good defence against action of restitution of conjugal right, law does not permit wronged spouse inflicted with mental cruelty to commit cruelty against wrong doer in retaliation . If counter cruelty of different nature is proved, simply on basis of such counter cruelty, divorce can be granted.

Court:CHHATTISGARH HIGH COURT
Respondent wife consumed huge amount of sleeping pills in absence of appellant-husband, on account of which she had to be admitted in Hospital. This act of Wife amounted to cruelty to Husband. In addition to treating Husband and his parents with cruelty,Wife also interfered in his official work, which adversely affected his official position. Wife also lodged complaint under Section 498A, IPC without disclosing fact of being treated with cruelty by Husband and his parents in connection with dowry demand. This conduct of Wife also reflects her cruelty of extreme degree towards Husband.

Court:ANDHRA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Wife filed criminal case against husband and her in-laws, which was held not proved by Criminal Court and maintenance which has been granted. These two factors prove strong desire of wife to be disassociated with husband and matrimonial home as a whole. She had no real intention to lead happy marital life with husband. Specific case of appellant husband that he was subjected to “mental cruelty” Divorce granted to Husband.

Court:MADHYA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Though condonation not pleaded as defence by Husband. It is the duty of Court to examine evidence of parties to find whether cruelty was condoned. Not proved that at any time during continuance of marriage, husband behaved with wife in such a way as to have condoned her acts of cruelty. Divorce granted.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
After departure Wife levelled such type of allegations which could not be Expected from Her which Amounts to Act of Cruelty

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Children Entitled to Claim Maintenance, for awarding maintenance to wife living separately, Court to conclude whether she is justified in living separately or not.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Wife did not behave rationally, making it impossible for husband to live with her. Wife even failed to prove her own allegation that she had been poisoned or husband was medically unfit.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Proceedings launched against wife under Section 182 of IPC upon investigation by the police that not just the complaint was false but also injuries were self inflicted by wife. Marriage dissolved by a decree of divorce.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
In matrimonial disputes, where hardly any documentary evidence surfaces, rival version have to be weighed in context of conduct of a reasonable person and/or if some documentary evidence viz. registered consumer of mobile number, etc.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Wife’s behaviour towards Husband and his family members was abusive, lacked respect, understanding, companionship and trust. The wife failed to substantiate her contention that respondent husband is living in adultery. Unsubstantiated allegations of adultery amounts to cruelty.

Court:PATNA HIGH COURT
Filing of false criminal complaint against husband and family members under Section 498A, IPC and other allied Sections of IPC, constitutes matrimonial cruelty. Marriage solemnized between parties dissolved on ground of cruelty.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
No justifiable reason on part of wife for not allowing mother of husband to live with family of husband. It is mental torture for husband in not permitting old aged widowed mother who was forced to live in village after death of her elder son with whom she was living earlier.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
The Supreme Court of India in this landmark judgment explains the term ‘Cruelty’ by Wife and Condonation.

Court:Bombay High Court
Wife not giving sexual satisfaction to Husband. Husband entitled to get the decree of divorce in his favour on the ground of mental cruelty and desertion.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
Wife is not able to discharge her marital obligations. Evident that it has become impossible for the Husband to reside with the her. Divorce granted.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
Not allowing husband to consummate marriage inspite of his pursuation that it was an essential aspect of married life amounts to cruelty.

Court:Bombay High Court
Taunts, constant nagging, violence and insulting behaviour by Wife amounts to cruelty.

Court:KERALA HIGH COURT
The act of living together or sharing bed with another man itself amounts to cruelty. Marriage dissolved.

Court:Rajasthan High Court
The Wife has deserted her Husband without any reasonable cause and without his consent and it amounts to cruelty.

Court:Gauhati High Court
Leaving the nuptial home frequently after marriage and final departure within a period of one year from the date of marriage amoutns to cruelty. Divorce granted to Husband.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
Insisting to live separately from mother and sister of Husband without any valid reason is cruelty towards Husband. Divorce granted to Husband.

Court:Calcutta High Court
Inciting some other person to give blow on husband’s head is cruelty.

Court:Bombay High Court
Irresponsible, wild and baseless allegations of impotency of Husband amounts to cruelty. Divorce granted to husband.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
Giving Birth to illegitimate child is cruelty on the part of Wife towards Husband.

Court:Allahabad High Court
Getting rid of pregnancy without consent of Husband amounts to cruelty.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
Filing false complaint under Section 498A and 506 IPC amounts to cruelty.

Court:Andhra High Court
Filing a criminal case after divorce petition is cruelty.

Court:Allahabad High Court
False, scandalous, malicious, baseless and unproved allegations by one spouse on other is cruelty.

Court:Delhi High Court
False imputation of adultery is cruelty.

Court:Rajasthan High Court
False FIR under section 498A IPC amounts to cruelty.

Court:Madras High Court
False complaint given to dowry cell amounts to cruelty

Court:Allahabad High Court
Wife had been in the habit of keeping the husband under mental torture either by teasing his parents or spreading frivolous stories in the family which amounted to cruelty.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
False and frivolous allegations to superior officer about husband amounts to cruelty. Decree of divorce granted.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
False allegation by wife that husband is leading an adulterous life. Cruelty Proved.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
Serious but false allegations were made by the wife against her husband, even stating that he had put kerosene oil on her. Marriage dissolved by a decree of divorce on the ground of cruelty.

Court:Madhya Pradesh High Court
False allegation about character of husband and family members amounts to mental cruelty.Divorce granted.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
False allegation that husband’s plea for her treatment was a tactic to get rid of her. No cogent/reliable evidence.
Amounts to mental cruelty.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Husband’s petition for divorce on ground of wife’s cruelty. Allegations made by wife in her maintenance application u/s. 125 Cr.P.C. in her notice and written statement to divorce proceedings that husband is a drunkard, gambler and womanizer. Allegations based on hearsay and Unfounded and false to the knowledge of wife and amount to crulety, decree of divorce confirmed.

Court:PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
False Allegation by wife that Husband contracted second marriage during subsistance of first marriage with her. Such allegations against her husband constitute mental cruelty on her part.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Making Grave but False allegation by Wife of attempt to burn her by Husband is Cruelty.

Court:Calcutta High Court
Wife Doubting that husband was in illicit connection with his own sister-in-law amounts to cruelty.

Court:SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Denial of sexual intercourse amounts to cruelty.

Court:Calcutta High Court
There was no just reason for depriving the Husband of the Company of the wife and that itself is an instance of mental cruelty.

Court:PUNJAB & HARYANA HIGH COURT
Day-to-day behaviour of Wife disturbed mental peace and harmony of Husband — Amounting to legal cruelty — Wife may not be of unsound mind, but her peculiar ways of behaviour proved by respondent sufficient to constitute legal cruelty.

Court:RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Conviction of Wife for Murdering Her Mother-in-law, does Amount to Cruelty on Husband : Even if Wife is Acquitted, it shall not be Humanly Possible for Husband to Stay or Cohabitate Once Again with Respondent-wife and to Accept her as his Wife.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
Constantly insulting Husband in presence of friends amounts to cruelty.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Making false and reckless allegations on the character of the spouse amounts to mental cruelty.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
In different attitude of respondent towards the appellant’s relatives( brother, mother,father etc.) this conduct of respondent amounted to cruelty against husband.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Wife alleging husband of an incestuous relationship with his cousin sister amounts to cruelty .

Court:Andhra Pradesh High Court
Relationship between parties irretrievably broken and because of non-co-operation and hostile attitude of respondent wife, appellant husband subjected to serious traumatic experience : It can safely be termed as ‘cruelty’ within meaning of Section 13(1)(ia) of Act . Acts of respondent and her parents saying appellant cannot perform sexual intercourse amounts to cruelty.

Court:Rajasthan High Court
False Allegation by Wife that husband used to beat her amounts to cruelty.

Court:Karnataka High Court
The Wife abused Husband in public and treated the Husband with such cruelty as to cause reasonable apprehension in his mind that it would be harmful or injurious for him to live with her.

Court:DELHI HIGH COURT
Wife got the pregnancy terminated without the consent of the Husband and thus caused mental cruelty to him. termination of pregnancy without the consent of the husband amounts to cruelty

Court:BOMBAY HIGH COURT
Altercation or conflict between husband and wife does not amount to “cruelty” and cannot attract provisions of Section 498A.
Conviction cannot be based on sentimental approach.

Court:ANDHRA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Husband and Wife lived together for period of 11 months and after desertion by wife disassociation of husband continuing since 1994 for about 13 years. This is absolutely sufficient to grant divorce .

Court:MADHYA PRADESH HIGH COURT
Amount of maintenance can be reduced if it is justifiable.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
By withdrawing herself from society of husband she has treated him with cruelty Divorce granted to husband.

Court:Madhya Pradesh High Court
Conduct of wife amounting to cruelty though there is no danger of its repetition amounts to cruelty, divorce granted.

Court:Allahabad High Court
False and unnecessary complaints to superiors of husband in his office amounts to cruelty, divorce granted

Court:Delhi High Court
False and unnecessary complaints to Husband’s employer and other Authorities amounts to cruelty , divorce granted.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
Wife Attempting to commit suicide amounts to cruelty, divorce granted.

Court:Supreme Court of India
Calling husband a mental patient amounts to cruelty, divorce granted.

Court:Madhya Pradesh High Court
Calling Husband lame and less qualified is cruelty, divorce granted.

Court:Delhi High Court
Birth of illegitimate child , divorce granted

Court:Himachal Pradesh High Court
Beating up and threatening family of Husband amounts to cruelty-Divorce granted.

Court:Madhya Pradesh High Court
Beating husband and his family members amounts to cruelty, divorce granted.

Court:Delhi High Court Court
Showing an attitude of disregard to husband’s feelings and self respect amounts to cruelty, decree of judicial separation passed.

Court:Andhra High Court
Attempting to throw child on road.

Court:Punjab-Haryana High Court
Attempt to commit suicide by the wife amounts to cruelty, divorce granted.

Court:Rajasthan High Court
Atrocious allegations, actions and behaviour by wife.

Court: Delhi High Court
False allegation of extra marital relationship – Divorce granted to husband.

Court:Andhra High Court
False allegation by the wife that husband was a womaniser. Divorce granted to Husband.

Court:Orissa High Court
False allegation that the husband was a drunkard.

Court:Calcutta High Court
Wife asking Husband to get separated from parents and brothers is cruelty.

Court: Rajasthan High Court
False allegation that husband was impotent . Divorce granted.

Court: Rajasthan High Court
Abusing Husband Time and Again is cruelty divorce granted.

Court: Himachal Pradesh High Court
Abstaining from sexual relationship is cruelty, divorce granted.

Court: Supreme Court of India
Stubborn attitude and inexplicably on respondent. Divorce granted

Court: Supreme Court of India
Defination of Mental Cruelty. In case of mental cruelty it will not be a correct approach to take an instance of misbehavior in isolation and then pose the question whether such behavior is sufficient by itself to cause mental cruelty.

Court: Supreme Court of India
Suicide Threats a Ground for Divorce e

Court: Punjab-Haryana High Court
It is well settled law, that filing of false criminal case against the spouse is an act of cruelty, on the basis of which the spouse suffering, is entitled to decree of divorce.

Court: Punjab-Haryana High Court
Threats & attempts to commit suicide & lodging false 498A is ground for divorce

Court: HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Cruelty and Condonation defined, Husband granted divorce as wife not willing to give witness

Court: HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND
Husband won the divorce on the grounds of Cruelty by wife, divroce granted with limited alimony

Court: HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Roping in relatives in false cases amounts to cruelty towards husband

Court: Madras High Court

Mental Cruelty, husband granted divorce by HC

Court: Madras High Court
Transfer application under 23(3) CPC

Court: Madras High Court
Audio CD evidence in matrimonial case

Court: HIGH COURT OF DELHI
2 or 3 incidences sufficient for Divorce on ground of cruelty

Court: Madras High Court
Judicial Seperation granted on application of Divorce

Court: Supreme Court of India
Judicial Seperation is not a divorce, doesn’t snap matrimonial ties

Court: Bombay High Court
Cruelty defined, divorce decree reaffirmed by High Court

Court: Punjab-Haryana High Court
Mental Cruelty defined, husband granted divorce 

Court: HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

Repeated Suicide threats amounts mental cruelty, is valid divorce ground

Court: Supreme Court of India
Mental Cruelty Defined, termination of pregnancy, calling parents Ghosts is mental cruelty towards husband.

Court: Supreme Court of IndiaI
Application for medical assessment of mental condition of wife allowed in a matrimonial dispute at insistence of husband.

Court: PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
False cases of 498A, 125 CrPC, amount to cruelty against Husband

Court: PUNJAB AND HARYANA HIGH COURT
Wife got the petitioner arrested in the proceedings under Section 107/151 Cr.P.C. caused mental cruelty to the husband. Husband entitled to divorce

Court: MADHYA PRADESH HIGH COURT
False case amount in cruelty leads to Divorce

Court: MADRAS HIGH COURT
Divorce on Denial of Sex

Court: SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
False complaint, family arrest -ground for Divorce

Court: Mumbai High Court
Ex-parte divorce to husband on basis of acquital in 498A

Court: Madhya Pradesh High Court
Cruelty and Desertion grounds for Divorce