False Gang Rape Case? 2 Men Acquitted After 8 Years In Jail: Calcutta High Court Cites Lack Of Evidence
WEST BENGAL: The Calcutta High Court has set aside the convictions and life sentences of two men in a gang rape case, after they spent eight years in prison.
A Division Bench of Justice Rajasekhar Mantha and Justice Anuj Singh held that the prosecution failed to produce sufficient medical and forensic evidence to establish the charges against the accused.
The case dates back to 19 August 2006, when a minor girl was returning home after attending a music programme in a neighbouring village in Bardhaman, West Bengal.
She alleged that three men caught her, gagged her with her dupatta and gang-raped her. Her father subsequently lodged a police complaint.
The girl was initially treated by a local practitioner before being taken to a hospital. However, she reportedly refused a medical examination, stating that she was menstruating.
On 17 July 2013, charges were framed against the accused. On 10 October 2018, the Trial Court convicted the appellants under Section 376(2)(g) IPC and subsequently sentenced them to rigorous life imprisonment, along with a fine of Rs 5,000 each.
The men challenged their conviction before the High Court.
The High Court expressed “surprise” at the Trial Court's reasoning that the defence had not specifically denied the occurrence of rape during cross-examination.
The Bench held that the burden of proving criminal charges rests with the prosecution. An accused cannot be convicted merely because the defence failed to challenge a particular allegation during cross-examination.
The Court acknowledged that a rape conviction can be based solely on the testimony of the complainant. However, it stressed the importance of reliable and consistent evidence.
Criticising the prosecution for its failure to establish the allegations, the Court observed:
“Except for recording an allegation of rape, there is no material medical evidence to show any sexual assault on the victim.”
The High Court also pointed out serious lapses in the police investigation. The police neither seized the girl's clothes nor sent them for forensic examination.
The Court also found inconsistencies between the girl's testimony and her mother's statement recorded by the doctor.
While examining the available evidence, the High Court found that the investigation and prosecution failed to establish the appellants' guilt.
On 13 November 2026, the Calcutta High Court allowed the criminal appeal, set aside the convictions and life sentences, and directed the immediate release of the appellants, provided they were not wanted in any other case.
After spending eight years behind bars, the men finally secured acquittal in the gang rape case.
EXPLANATORY TABLE OF LAWS AND SECTIONS
| Law / Section | What It Means | Application In This Case |
|---|---|---|
| Section 376 IPC | Prescribes punishment for rape. | Court examined whether the rape allegations were sufficiently proved. |
| Section 376(2)(g) IPC (old provision) | Prescribes punishment for gang rape. | Appellants were convicted under this provision before being acquitted. |
| Section 161 CrPC | Allows police to examine witnesses and record their statements. | Witness statements were examined during the proceedings. |
| Section 164 CrPC | Allows a Magistrate to record statements and confessions. | Mentioned in connection with the evidence. |
| Section 4 POCSO Act, 2012 | Prescribes punishment for penetrative sexual assault against a child. | Referred to while discussing the evidentiary requirements for conviction. |
| Section 6 POCSO Act, 2012 | Prescribes punishment for aggravated penetrative sexual assault. | Referred to while discussing the reliability of a complainant's testimony. |
| Section 437A CrPC | Requires accused persons to execute bonds to appear before a higher court if required. | Appellants were directed to execute bonds valid for six months. |
| Section 481 BNSS, 2023 | Corresponding provision of Section 437A CrPC. | Referred to in the release directions. |
CASE DETAILS
| Particular | Details |
|---|---|
| Case Title | Palash Das & Anr. v. The State of West Bengal |
| Court | Calcutta High Court |
| Jurisdiction | Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction |
| Bench | Justice Rajasekhar Mantha and Justice Anuj Singh |
| Case Number | C.R.A. 669 of 2018 |
| Sessions Trial Number | 16 of 2013 |
| Sessions Case Number | 3 of 2012 |
| Appellants' Counsel | Dipanjan Chatterjee, Sonali Das |
| State Counsel | Dr. Pradip Banerjee (APP), Sankalpa Bhattacharjee, Srestha Ghosh |
| Date of Judgment | 13 November 2026 |
| Decision | Criminal appeal allowed; convictions and life sentences set aside. |
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Eight Years of Freedom Lost: Men spent eight years behind bars before securing acquittal.
- Allegations Cannot Replace Evidence: A woman's accusation alone cannot establish a man's guilt.
- Investigative Failures Destroy Men's Lives: Men suffered because of serious lapses in the police investigation.
- Judicial Accountability Matters: Life imprisonment based on insufficient evidence demands serious scrutiny.
- Acquittal Cannot Undo Injustice: Men walked free, but the justice system cannot return eight stolen years of their lives.
Share Your Thoughts
Comments are moderated before publication.