Summary:
In a crucial victory against false rape cases, the Allahabad High Court modified the summoning order, ruling that the allegations did not justify an attempted rape charge. The court recognized the misuse of stringent rape laws and downgraded the charges, preventing innocent men from being trapped in fabricated cases. This judgment highlights the growing abuse of rape laws to settle personal scores and reinforces that serious allegations must be backed by solid evidence, not just verbal claims.
Facts of the Case
- Accused: Akash, Pawan, and Ashok (family members).
- Complainant: Asha Devi (mother of the alleged victim).
- Incident Date: 10.11.2021
- Allegations
- Pawan offered a ride to the 14-year-old girl with her mother’s permission.
- Akash and Pawan allegedly groped her and tried to pull her beneath a culvert.
- Witnesses arrived, and the accused fled.
- Ashok (Pawan’s father) allegedly threatened the complainant later.
- Legal Proceedings
- The Trial Court charged Akash and Pawan with attempt to rape (Section 376 IPC read with Section 18 of POCSO Act).
- Ashok was charged under Sections 504 and 506 IPC for criminal intimidation.
- Accused challenged the order, stating that the case was a revenge-driven false complaint.
Legal Provisions Involved
- Section 376 IPC (Rape) – Severe punishment for rape.
- Section 18 POCSO Act (Attempt to Commit Offense) – Penalizes attempts to commit sexual crimes against minors.
- Section 354(B) IPC (Intent to Disrobe a Woman) – Covers molestation with intent to undress.
- Section 9/10 POCSO Act (Aggravated Sexual Assault on a Minor) – Punishment for sexual assault on children under 12 years old.
Arguments
Accused’s Side (The Truth)
- False case filed out of revenge – The accused had a prior legal dispute with the complainant’s family.
- Allegations exaggerated – The incident did NOT meet the legal standard for attempted rape.
- Malicious prosecution – The case was filed after a chargesheet was issued against the complainant’s family in another case.
- No medical proof, no independent witnesses – The case relied only on unverified statements with no forensic evidence.
Complainant’s Side (Weak & Suspicious Claims)
- Claimed molestation and an attempt to drag the girl, but never alleged actual rape or penetration.
- Wanted the accused to face full rape charges, despite zero medical or forensic proof.
- Argued that courts should blindly accept the allegations and send the case to trial.
Court’s Observations – No More Fake Rape Cases!
Serious Charges Need Solid Proof!
- Attempt to rape requires clear intent and action towards committing rape—that was NOT proven here.
- Touching clothes or pulling at garments is NOT rape or attempt to rape!
Fake Allegations Are Destroying Innocent Men’s Lives!
- A single false rape case can ruin a man’s career, reputation, and future—even before trial!
- Courts must be cautious and not allow women to use rape laws as a tool of revenge!
Revenge Case Clearly Proven!
- The accused had a legal dispute with the complainant’s family before this case.
- Filing this case only after their family got into legal trouble proves a clear motive for revenge!
Courts Must Stop Blindly Trusting Accusers!
- Real victims deserve justice, but false accusers must also be punished!
- Fake rape cases damage the credibility of real survivors and waste valuable judicial resources.
Conclusion – A Step Towards Stopping Misuse of Rape Laws!
- High Court REJECTED the rape charge and changed it to lesser offenses under Section 354(B) IPC and Section 9/10 POCSO Act.
- This prevented a clear case of legal blackmail and false allegations.
- A big step forward in protecting men from false rape cases!
Comments from the author of this website
False rape cases have become a tool for legal terrorism, where one baseless accusation is enough to destroy a man’s life before trial even begins. Men are arrested first, humiliated, and forced to prove their innocence while false accusers walk free. The legal system must stop blindly believing allegations without solid proof. Courts cannot treat men as criminals based on mere words. Urgent reforms are needed—no rape case should proceed without medical and forensic evidence, and false accusers must face strict punishment. Enough is enough—men must stand up and fight against this blatant misuse of the law!
Final Thoughts – Justice, Not Witch Hunts!
False rape cases ruin lives. No man should be guilty without proof. Courts must demand evidence, not blind belief.
🔴 No proof, no case!
🔴 Punish false accusers!
🔴 Justice must be fair for all!
Men must fight back against legal abuse! 🚨
Read Complete Judgement Here